Electric / ultrasonic rechargeable power toothbrushes
Current situation: Sonicare Intelliclean (discontinued).
- excellent at preventing dental problems: my dental health had a major improvement (not necessarily due to the Intelliclean alone), and then plateaued at a high level for 4 years
- never needed any sort of battery level indicator, as the battery lasts longer than any trip made without the charger (2 weeks)
- the internal toothpaste sacs proved clumsy
- gets really dirty inside; must clean every 3 months or less
- heads are extremely hard to find as of 2009-Jul, and expensive
- never used the multiple cleaning speeds - unless you have incredibly sensitive gums, you will just use the maximum speed every day
Technologies
- manual - inferior to power toothbrushes
- rotary (Braun Oral-B)
- sonic - beats rotary in PubMed test in every aspect, as of 1997
- requires adjusting your teeth and skull to the vibration (days/weeks)
- ultrasonic - Ultreo (which shut down in 2008-Dec)
Candidates
NOTE: to prevent gunk buildup in the Sonicare, use the $5 Sonic Seal.
Oral B S-320 Sonic Complete Rechargeable Power Toothbrush
- "'CrissCross' bristles are angled to reach deep and clean between teeth, while 'Power Tip' bristles are longer to reach more difficult spots"
- cheaper head replacements (3 for $20) than the Sonicare Elite
Oral-B Triumph Professional Care 9400 Power Toothbrush â
- + "The rubber tips on the floss head brush is (sic!) extremely effective at getting in-between the teeth"
- - planned obsolescence in the manual: "Battery removal at the end of the productâs useful life: Open the handle as shown, remove the battery and dispose of it according to local environmental regulations. "
- rotating motion with MicroPulse bristles
- - most extra features (vs. older Professional Care models) are gimmicks; the FlossAction head works on the older models as well, despite official claims to the contrary
- allegedly no improvement over the 8000 series, but the Research section on the product page claims the overall cleaning results are better than in the ProfessionalCare 8000
- quad-pacer
- pressure sensor stops pulsations when you brush too hard
- - advertised as multi-voltage but actually not
- automatically recognizes the FlossAction head
- gets dirty easily because the brush heads collect water/toothpaste, but is easy to clean
- NiMH battery; charge often
- repeatedly reported to feel like a drill when compared to Sonicare
- the current brush time is displayed on the handle so you can't always look at it; apparently this "feature" was rightly removed since it seemed to cause short circuits due to moisture
- clumsy reviewers complain about bad button placement causing brush switch-off
- all 1-star Amazon reviews are from clueless idiots
My review
- with the Floss Action head, the cleaning feels more thorough than with the Sonicare Intelliclean
- the head is smaller and round, so you can reach behind the premolars farthest back in the mouth. I couldn't do that with the Sonicare's oval head.
- does feel like a drill, but only for the first use. On the second use, it feels about 30% as intense as the first time, and on he 3rd use, I got almost completely used to it.
- the handle display is of very little use, and you can't see it anyway while brushing (usually). If you really want to see it,
- brush against a mirror
- briefly stop the toothbrush, look at the display, then resume brushing. The toothbrush remembers when you left off.
- the reviewers who posted about bad button placement must've been clumsy. I never accidentally pressed any button while brushing. Also, the buttons need a pretty firm press to activate.
- it does not replace flossing (no toothbrush does), and this is clearly mentioned in the user manual
- it didn't get dirty (so far, after 3 weeks of use). The head is attached in such a way, through only a vibrating metal rod, that there's not much place for grime to accumulate anyway. By comparison, the Sonicare Intelliclean developed an entire ecosystem of gunk inside the toothbrush head.
Oral B Triumph 9900 Toothbrush with Smart Guide
- - destroyed if attempting to replace the battery. Idiotic planned obsolescence.
- ? "wireless, portable interactive display that gives improved feedback on brushing technique, time and pressure": time - OK, albeit useless since the brush signals every 30 seconds; pressure - senses when you press too hard, although it takes a lot of pressure to do that; but technique?! Actually it has you brush the quadrants in the same order all the time, while the better technique is to randomize the order.
- - changing modes can only be done from the wireless Smart Guide
- rotating motion, with "MicroPulses", but feels way slow compared to Sonicare, or may clean better
- doesn't remember the last mode but fortunately always starts in the "clean" mode (most powerful)
- SmartGuide is overrated
- - fogs up
- - gunk build-up? (from uneducated reviewer)
- + waterproof
- + automatically detects head type
- + user-confirmed dual voltage
- universally favorable reviews of the Flossing Action head, but that works on simpler brushes as well.
- the 9950 apparently differs from the 9900 only in that is ships with a different number of brush heads
Philips Sonicare Advance 4100 Sonic Power Toothbrush
- + uses standard AA batteries
- no quad-pacer
- - collects gunk
Philips Sonicare Essence 5300 Power Toothbrush
- - get the e5500 instead
Philips Sonicare Essence e5500 Power Toothbrush
- + like the 5300 but has a quad-timer that beeps every 30 seconds for each dental quadrant
- - collects slime
Sonicare Elite 7300, 7500
- almost identical, except the 7500 has 3 extra gimmicks:
- battery indicator
- dual-speed (low speed for sensitive areas)
- luxury holder
- non-slip handle grip
- battery replacement hack
Sonicare FlexCare
- + does not collect gunk
- - less efficient than the Advance because of smaller head and less vibration
- - uses Lithium-ion batteries (environmentally safer, no memory effect; but fewer charge cycles than the Ni-Cd in the Advance and Elite series)
- - design flaw: the speed change button is placed such that the holding hand presses it during brushing (repeated complaints)
- - doesn't remember cleaning mode and resets to the 1-minute QuickClean mode every time
- - battery not replaceable
- - various users report it breaking soon
Showing changes from previous revision. Removed | Added